
In order to a be consistently successful grouse hunter you need three things: competent shooting skills, a good dog that works within range if it’s a flusher, or is staunch if it’s a pointer and, lastly, a thorough knowledge of the bird. Of these three, I believe knowledge of the bird is the most important.
I am fascinated by anything you can do with a shotgun. Shooting targets, hunting birds or just admiring the craftsmanship of a well-made double gun – if it has to do with a shotgun I’m up for it. If I had to pick just one thing to do though, it would be hunting grouse. I’ve gunned every different kind of game bird the US has to offer, yet nothing thrills me as much as watching a grouse fold at my shot.
In my early years of bird hunting in New York, decent duck and goose hunting existed, but the bird of choice was the ruffed grouse. Woodcock were a nice addition because they cooperated well for a pointing dog, and they dramatically increased your bird contact. In those days we would often move only three grouse in a day, so the 20 to 40 woodcock that we came into contact with would really spice up the experience.
Ruffed grouse season in New York runs from October 1 to February 28, and with a season that long you have ample opportunity to learn some things about the bird.
My hunting partners – my father Bud, Uncle John and his son Johnny – and I had a rule: when we flushed a grouse we would follow it in order to get another shot, but if the bird eluded us three times we would leave it and find another. This gave us an opportunity to study the way birds responded to pressure, and in particular how the same bird reacted to it over and over. The birds we encountered repeatedly and were unable to harvest we called “PhD birds”, because they had a doctorate in eluding the bird hunter.
I remember one bird that lived in a cover that was part of the local pheasant club. Stocked pheasants were the primary target of visiting hunters, but if their dogs worked a grouse they would surely have a go at it. Overtime this bird became so wary that if you slammed the truck door in his vicinity, you would hear him flush into a thick stand of pines where even dynamite wouldn’t have dislodged him.
 |
| With 22 years of competitive shooting under his belt, Andy Duffy has collected numerous national and international shooting titles. His conviction that “perfect practice makes perfect” has paid off, and in addition to shooting competitively Duffy is an expert shooting instructor and avid grouse hunter. To find out more visit www.andyduffy.com. |
One day I decided to sneak into the cover from the backside, placing myself between the bird and his security cover. I got into position as quietly as possible, and at a pre-arranged time my cousin drove into the parking lot and slammed the truck door. The grouse flushed straight over my head and I folded it just as it entered the pines. I must admit I felt a little remorse about defeating such a worthy opponent. After all, it took two of us outsmart a creature with a brain the size of pecan.
Experiences like this were the start of a pattern of behavior that I have used ever since to hunt grouse – in a word – strategy. In order to be a consistently successful grouse hunter you need three things: competent shooting skills, a good dog that works within range if it’s a flusher, or is staunch if it’s a pointer and, lastly, a thorough knowledge of the bird. Of these three, I believe knowledge of the bird is the most important.
Growing Grouse Savvy
In the course of 35 years spent chasing grouse, I’ve had thousands of contacts with the king. What I’ve learned has only increased my admiration of the wily bird, so we’ll examine a few of the things I’ve learned about the bird first.
Every predator in the woods loves to eat grouse, but the most efficient predators are hawks and owls. Grouse that develop anti-avian predator behavior survive longer than their fellows. How many times have you heard a grouse flush and when you looked for the bird all you could see were two wingtips on either side of a tree trunk? A grouse will always try to put an obstacle between itself and what it determines to be a danger. Even just a split second head start can mean life or death to a grouse – especially if the predator is a goshawk.
Goshawks are accipiters – they can accelerate and overtake a grouse in flight on a horizontal flight path. Falcons, by comparison, require altitude from which they “dive” or “stoop” to catch their prey. Far and away the goshawk is the most effective predator of ruffed grouse, with the great horned owl a close second.
A grouse in flight is vulnerable, so their first line of defense when feeling threatened is to hunker down and hide. A grouse that hears a hunter approaching will most often do just that – and if the hunter keeps moving, the bird will let him walk right by.
A lone hunter without a dog can improve his flush rate if he walks erratically and stops often in likely-looking cover. The grouse hears the hunter stop, thinks it has been spotted and will often flush in order to escape the perceived danger. This is also why you hear about someone stopping to cross a fence and after unloading the gun and placing it safely on the other side of the fence, the bird blows out in the open and is perfectly within range. This has happened to me so many times I’m convinced grouse know what they are doing when they see a hunter halfway over a barbwire fence.
Knowing the preferences of the bird will help you to organize the most advantageous approach to different hunting scenarios – ones that will result in the best possible chance for success. One such consideration is that grouse will only fly across an open field if they have no alternative path. If you find a grouse out on a peninsula of cover, it will try to fly back past you unless there are multiple hunters (including the dog) or there is more cover a very short distance away.
Another technique you can try is to look for different types of food sources. Different times of the year grouse will use covers based on food availability and proximity to secure cover. Later in the season look for open water, like a small stream, as this becomes an important component.
Yet another consideration when hunting grouse are the conditions. I call this the “sphere of influence.” It’s a term I first heard about when reading a book on human body language. The author said a person requires a zone of about 18", outside of which lies the normal area of social interaction. If in the course of the day a stranger enters into your 18" space, the initial reaction is to take a step back.
The sphere of influence can vary depending on the environment. Consider a crowded elevator, by necessity the sphere of influence gets smaller due to the circumstances. The same thing happens with grouse. Anything that compromises the grouse’s main line of defense – eyes and ears – will increase the sphere of influence and make the bird nervous and jumpy. An example of these compromises is a windy day. The trees are moving around, and as they can’t hear as keenly they will become more nervous and blow out in a hurry. A dog that can handle a grouse on a windy day merits his own room in your house!
The human voice will also result in a more agitated bird. If your hunting partner is constantly yelling at his dog, you are decreasing your grouse contacts dramatically. The bird will simply walk deeper into cover at the noise, and because it takes you longer to get to the point the bird is long gone by the time you get there.
There are a lot of reasons why grouse don’t cooperate, but there are some conditions that work towards the hunter’s advantage.
Damp conditions are generally the best. A slight misting rain has the dual advantage of quieting the woods and making grouse reluctant to move around anymore than necessary. It’s also the very best scenting conditions for your dog, with the added benefit of keeping him cool. The best thing to do is to look for a pattern of grouse behavior as you hunt – and make adjustments accordingly.
I remember one hunt in late January, the first two days we hunted in rain and sleet with temperatures that hovered just above freezing. The morning of the third day dawned sunny and cold, with no wind. Grouse were everywhere! They emerged from the cover, fed, found a patch of sun and had no desire to leave it. The worst dog in the world would have looked like a hero that day. The point is conditions will change and influence how grouse will react on a given day, and you need to plan your strategy accordingly.
The best thing to do is to look for a pattern as you hunt – and then adjust how you come into the dog on point, or how you work through a cover with your flusher.
Working with your Bird Dog
Now we consider the dog aspect of the successful grouse hunting equation. I’ve observed that the majority of folks who hunt with pointing dogs generally go right to the dog on point. This is fine if you are hunting quail in Georgia – but it doesn’t work on grouse. A really good dog knows that grouse won’t tolerate a dog right on top of them, so they point at a distance. In addition grouse cover is generally so thick you won’t get a shot if you are right with the dog when the grouse flushes. When you have two hunters and a dog on point near the trail, one hunter should go deep into the cover and come to the point well in front of the dog, and begin moving toward the other hunter. Hopefully the bird flushes away from one hunter and gives the other a nice shot.
Flushing dogs are both easier, and harder, to work with in the grouse woods. A pointing dog allows you to move leisurely down the trail until the dog goes on point – then it’s game time. With a flushing dog you have to be ready all the time, but with a dog that hunts close it’s easy to read when he gets birdy, and it can be some of the most exciting grouse hunting that exists.
Sometimes even the best dogs look foolish when working grouse. It pays to remember that you’ve botched an easy straightaway shot now and then when you see him bumping a bird. A little forgiveness goes a long way toward a successful, rewarding hunt.
Better Gunning Tactics
Finally we’re ready to discuss actually shooting a grouse. You may find this hard to believe, but they don’t travel at the speed of light. A ruffed grouse in flight is actually one of the slowest game birds in existence. The problem is the habitat where you find them only gives you the barest glimpse of them. From this you have to judge their angle, speed and distance.
The thing to know is your first glimpse of a flushing grouse is almost always followed up by a better look. If you make efficient use of the first look, your chances for success increase drastically. Get an impression of the direction of flight then look out ahead. Most often the bird will cross another opening and this is where you should make your move. Remember – they are slow. Swing your gun in from behind and get to the bird’s head or front edge.
In all the years I have hunted grouse I have only seen a lead on one that resulted in success. It was a bird my cousin succeeded in knocking a cloud of feathers from at the top of a hill. Fortunately I was at the bottom of the hill and killed the bird at about 55 yards, and even then gap between the bird and the barrel were minimal.
The most common error in shooting grouse is shooting too fast. How many times have you dumped both barrels only to watch the bird fly across an open trail? The best advice I ever received came from a 95-year-old ex-market hunter from Virginia. (He shot ruffed grouse for restaurants in Virginia.) He had his best results after leaving corn in the road and waiting for their heads to line up. Though he was only half-joking, the real trick is to try to see their eye. He said if you could see their eye, you will shoot them in the head.
I only see the eye on about 5% of the grouse I bag – but I’m working on it! If I do see the eye when I make the shot, there are almost never pellets in the body. Aim small and miss small.
When all the different aspects come together and you are able to put a grouse in the bag, it is one of the most rewarding experiences a gunner can have. Achieving it consistently takes a very real effort on many different levels. The best part is that just when you think you have ruffed grouse figured out, they do something you’ve never seen before.